Anti Detri What?


When talking about Anti Detriment Payments (ADP), the response is often, Anti Detri what? But the reality is ADP are a little known part of superannuation that can be of large value.

An ADP is a additional payment, paid on death, to eligible dependents on receipt of a superannuation lump sum death benefit.  It is meant to be a refund of the contributions tax paid by the member over the life of their superannuation benefit. As it is almost impossible for any member to calculate the actual contribution tax paid over the life of their superannuation, the ATO have provided a formula to calculate it (this formula is provided at the end of this blog).  ADP are funded by providing the fund with a tax deduction equal to the ADP grossed up by the superannuation tax rate of 15% but not all superannuation funds pay ADP though.

You might be thinking, this is all a bit complicated and so what?

This is not a payment which is only applicable to deaths in younger people and it isn't only applicable for deaths in older people.  It's a payment which is available at any age!  So, how much can this benefit be?

Lets have a look at John, a 40 year old with a wife and 2 children, who unfortunately has been diagnosed with a terminal illness.  He has a superannuation balance of $300,000 (100% taxable component) with an eligible service date of 1 July 1993 and an insurance death benefit of $120,000.  Often people would claim the insurance benefit (virtually all death benefits will pay on diagnosis of a terminal illness) and then withdrawal the entire $420,000 under the terminal illness condition of release of superannuation.  They then can use the funds to enjoy their final months together and leave the spouse with the balance so she isn't waiting for the death benefit after death.  If you don't have anyone eligible for an ADP, then this would be a good strategy.

Unfortunately, when you withdrawal your superannuation balance prior to death under terminal illness, you are no longer eligible for ADP.   In this case for John, his ADP could be $52,941, that's right, over $50,000! That is a lot of extra money for the spouse and children.  I've seen people miss out on this sort of money. Even if they wanted some funds from superannuation prior to Johns death, they could have rolled the majority of the balance over to another fund that pays an ADP, then claim the insurance benefit, and withdrawal those funds.  It is important not to mix the insurance proceeds with the superannuation balance if you want to withdrawal some funds prior to death.

ADP can also apply to older people.  As the superannuation system ages, so does the number of retirees dying with a superannuation balance remaining.  Some funds, but not many, also pay ADP from pensions as well as accumulation accounts.

Bob is 74 and has $450,000 in a pension. He has an eligible service date of 1 July 1980.  If Bob has his pension in a fund which offers ADP and Bob's wife Mary receives his superannuation as a lump sum, she could receive an ADP of $64,671.

So, to conclude, I would just like to run through a few main points when it comes to ADP:
  • Not all superannuation funds offer it and even less pensions offer it. Ensure yours does.
  • To receive an ADP, the beneficiary must be a spouse, former spouse or child.  They must receive the benefit as a superannuation lump sum death benefit. Withdrawing funds prior to death or nominating a reversionary pensioner on a pension means they will not get it.
  • If the person receiving the ADP is to old to re contribute the funds back to superannuation, you need to determine if the ADP is worth it if there is negative tax and Centrelink implications by having the funds outside the superannuation environment.
  • It is very very difficult to get the benefit from a Self Managed Super Fund.  You need to have sufficient funds in reserves of the fund prior to death (which is essentially your own money), then you pay the reserves as an ADP (which again is your own money). Then the SMSF will receive a large tax deduction to carry forward so the funds are then recouped over many years of not paying tax within the fund. For people nearing retirement or in pension phase. This is of no use to them. For those who are paying tax within a SMSF, recouping a $50,000 or $60,000 ADP can take decades. 
If you would like any further information on Anti Detriment Payments or any other financial matter, please contact me on 1300 200 012 or glenn@precisionwm.com.au

The formula for calculating an ADP is in the picture below. Although it looks complicated, for people with an eligible service date (the date you first started working and received superannuation contributions) after 30 June 1983, it will simply be the taxable component of your superannuation fund multiplied by 17.647%.

Direct insurance - what's it all about?



Are you a stay at home parent that watches a little bit of day time TV, or have you had a sick day and watched TV during the day?  If you have, then you have more than likely seen the constant advertisements both in the commercial breaks and the infomercials during the morning TV shows for personal insurance; generally death cover and income protection.

I have to admit, they do a great job at advertising their insurance. With the background music, the acted out examples of someone being off work and needing income protection, happy families etc. and also someone ringing up to take out an insurance policy.  They also like to give you the cost of the cover in small frequencies, generally telling you the cost in a daily or weekly amount, so that it feels like it is less expensive. "$3 a day - less than a cup of coffee" sounds a lot better than "more than $1,000 per year". While $1,000 per year seems like a lot of money, $3 per day is nothing, right?

Don't get me wrong, I do believe many Australian's lack adequate personal insurance and if those advertisements help families take out additional cover, then this is a good thing.  But is it really as attractive as they make out? It doesn't take too long to see that the answer is a resounding no. If you visit the Real Insurance website, you can view their commercials to have a closer look and make a comparison.

In the commercial, it gives an example of a 36 year old female receiving $5,000 of income protection cover. The cost of this is $32.33 per month. Firstly, if you look at the small text in the advertisement, it says it is for cover with a 90 day waiting period, payable for 6 months. This means that in order for an individual to be entitled to receive any form of payment, their illness or injury would need to be serious enough to prevent them from working for 90 days.

Most Australian families with a mortgage do not have sufficient cash reserves to provide for the family for 90 days.  Also, the advertised benefit only lasts up to 6 months.  What happens then? There is a reasonable chance that an illness or injury, that is considered serious enough to keep you out of work for an initial period of 3 months, is likely to also prevent you from working for longer than the additional 6 month period (9 months in total).  According to Financial Advisers Australia, when a person is off work for more than 3 months, the average duration of claim is 4.2 years1.

The company’s Product Disclosure Statement for their income protection product also states that they will not pay a claim for a sickness or injury which is a direct or indirect result of a mental health disorder or illness.  According to AMP claims statistics from 2011, in 19% of all claims, the leading single cause of a claim, was as a direct or indirect result of mental illness2.

I have compared the cost of the policy advertised in the Real Insurance advertisement with a retail policy for the same 36 year old white collar non-smoking female.  You could have a policy which has a 90 day waiting period, however instead of the 6 month benefit period advertised by Real Insurance, the retail policy has a benefit period of 2 years (as a 6 month benefit period is not available on retail policies) and costs $32.26 per month (which is almost identical to the cost of the Real Insurance policy). This retail policy also includes cover for mental health illnesses, subject to underwriting. So for virtually the same cost, you have a longer benefit period as well as a policy that includes mental health, which as previously discussed is the leading cause of claim for income protection.

Other comparisons between direct and retain insurance, include:
  • Direct insurance only allows for self-ownership; the policy cannot be owned by superannuation, which is generally the best ownership option for death cover. In addition, the policy cannot be owned by a third party.
  • Direct insurance does not allow the option for level premiums. Level premiums allow the individual to take out cover that doesn't increase in cost each year as a result of the individual’s increasing age.  In the long term, this can result in significant savings for the policy holder.
  • Although direct insurance allows individuals to choose the benefit period on income protection, their maximum benefit periods are still considered short term (either 2 or 5 years). They do not provide the option for a benefit period to age 65.  This is not always suitable as generally speaking, most young people are going to be reliant on their income for a lot longer than 2 or 5 years.
There are also many other limitations with direct insurance policies and as I've shown above, they really are not the cheaper option.  To review your personal insurance and to discuss policies that will provide the most appropriate coverage for you and your family, please give me a call on 1300 200 012 or email at glenn@precisionwm.com.au.


1 http://www.faa.net.au/income_protection.html
2 https://www.amp.com.au/wps/amp/au/FileProxy?vigurl=%2Fvgn-ext-templating%2FfileMetadataInterface%3Fids%3Dde9fcbaafdc7d210VgnVCM1000001903400aRCRD

Kochie's hot investment tips



While watching Sunrise this morning, Kochie was talking about the Facebook share price and how Facebook had announced a 60% increase in revenue which resulted in the share price increasing by 19%. The funny thing was Samantha Armytage picked him up on it and said “and you told us not to buy Facebook shares” to which his reply was “that was after they had first listed and they went down, but they've come back up now.”

When we think back to around the time when Facebook were first listing, there was quite a lot of excitement and many people were keen to secure their piece of Facebook at the issue price of $38.  In doing a bit of research for this blog, I found an article from earlier this year which was titled “Facebook, One Year Later: What Really Happened in the Biggest IPO Flop Ever”. This article tells of a 68 year old widowed American woman ‘investing’ half of her life savings into Facebook; some $210,000. The article discussed how she had witnessed LinkedIn rise by 109% on its opening day, a year prior. This is not investing - this is gambling. After some initial excitement early on, Facebook’s stock quickly started falling after the company was listed and got as low as under $18, which was a decline of over 50% from their issue price. At that time, there was a lot of negative comments made regarding Facebook which included that they can’t actually make a profit, that most of their users are mobile and tablet users and as such that they are unable to effectively advertise to them, and that the issue share price of $38 was way too high as it’s not worth that much (although the Facebook Initial Public Offering was oversubscribed so if you were to value an asset based on what others would pay, then at $38 it was too cheap). Based on the comments on Sunrise this morning, it seems ‘Kochie’ was one of those media commentators that doubted Facebook as a worthy investment option at that time.

The article about the widowed woman was written when the Facebook stock price was $15 below her purchase price.  Essentially the article was all about Facebook’s launch being the biggest flop.

Facebooks stock price today is now up 29% from its original issue price, which over the 18 months gives an annualised return of 18.50% - which could hardly be considered a ‘flop’.  However, if the widowed woman had simply just purchased an index fund at the same time in the S&P 500 (America’s top 500 companies), her investment would now be up some 36% or an annualised return of almost 23% with much less risk.

This whole saga is a great example of why trying to pick stocks is fruitless. There is a lot of academic evidence to show that the whole stock picking business does nothing but serve the stock broker as stock brokers make a lot more money executing stock trades for clients than the returns that their clients receive. At Precision Wealth Management, our investment philosophy is not going to make you an overnight millionaire but it will achieve market returns with the potential for a small premium over the long term, which is better than what most investors actually achieve without the risk of the investment blowing up and losing everything. If you would like to know more, visit my website www.precisionwm.com.au and contact me.

Also, one other notable piece of advice from Kochie’s investment wisdom, came back in March 2009 when I was watching sunrise. It was the day after the market had bottomed and had risen sharply although at the time we didn't know that was going to be the bottom as it could have fallen again.  Kochie confidently announced that it was a dead cat bounce and not to buy in as there was still a lot of negative things happening in the economy.  Well as it turns out, it was the bottom and the market is up over 50% since then, so Kochie, perhaps you should just stick to hosting Sunrise and give up the investment tips.  I’m not saying I knew that was the bottom or not, but at least I know that I don’t know.

Disclaimer: I don’t watch Sunrise that much…I really don’t.